CAS vs SOA: Which Path Should Aspiring Actuaries Take?

When you're starting out as an actuary, one of the first big decisions you'll face is this: CAS or SOA? This isn’t just some random fork in the road—it’s the difference between building your career around property and casualty (P&C) insurance versus diving into life insurance, health insurance, pensions, or investments. If you're confused (or slightly panicking) about which one to choose, don’t worry. Let’s break it all down.

CAS vs. SOA: What Do They Even Mean?

• CAS: The Casualty Actuarial Society focuses on P&C insurance. Think auto insurance, homeowners insurance, or commercial liability.
• SOA: The Society of Actuaries deals with a broader range—life insurance, health insurance, pensions, and even enterprise risk management.

Both organizations help you become an actuary, but they shape your career in very different ways.

How to Choose Between CAS and SOA

This decision depends on where you want to work and what you want to specialize in. Here’s a quick cheat sheet:

1. If you’re into…
   • Numbers tied to disasters, accidents, or risks → CAS is your jam.
   • Long-term planning, like retirement funds or health plans → SOA is your go-to.
2. Think about your personality.
   • Are you more into quick-paced, event-driven industries? CAS might suit you better.
   • Prefer slower, strategic problem-solving? SOA could be the better fit.
3. Location Matters.
   • CAS-heavy areas: Regions with a lot of P&C companies, like Chicago or Hartford.
   • SOA-heavy areas: Think financial hubs like New York City or global consulting firms.

Exam Path: CAS vs. SOA

• CAS Exams:
  • Focused on P&C-specific knowledge.
  • You'll dig into concepts like pricing and reserving for natural disasters.
• SOA Exams:
  • Broader in scope.
  • You'll tackle life contingencies, pension mathematics, and health insurance concepts.

Both are tough, and both require years of dedication. But the biggest difference? SOA exams cover a wider range of topics, while CAS exams are more niche.

Career Paths for CAS and SOA Actuaries

• CAS Careers:
  • Pricing actuary for auto or homeowners insurance.
  • Risk management for catastrophic events (hurricanes, wildfires, etc.).
• SOA Careers:
  • Life insurance product development.
  • Retirement consulting.
  • Predictive analytics for healthcare costs.

Pro Tip: You can still pivot later, but the earlier you specialize, the easier it’ll be to carve out a niche.

FAQs About CAS vs. SOA

1. Can I switch from CAS to SOA (or vice versa)?
Yes, but it’s a grind. Exams from one society don’t fully overlap with the other, so expect to take extra tests if you switch tracks.

2. Which pays more: CAS or SOA?
Both pay exceptionally well. What matters more is the industry and location. But here’s the tea: SOA roles in finance or consulting often have higher earning potential at the start.

3. Do CAS actuaries work in consulting?
Yes! While many CAS actuaries work in insurance, others consult on P&C-related projects for big firms.

4. Which is easier: CAS or SOA exams?
Neither. The pass rates are low for both, and they test your patience (literally). Choose the one that aligns with your career goals because you’ll be grinding either way.

The Bottom Line: CAS vs. SOA?

If you’re dreaming of a career in P&C insurance, go with CAS. If you’re leaning toward life insurance, health insurance, or pensions, pick SOA. Still not sure? Explore internships in both fields to get a feel for what you enjoy.

And if you’re already looking for actuarial jobs, check out Acturhire—we’ve got the best opportunities for every career path, whether you’re CAS or SOA-bound.

‍